Contact phenomena are essential in understanding the behavior of mechanical systems. Existing computational approaches for simulating mechanical contact often encounter numerical issues, such as inaccurate physical predictions, energy conservation errors, and unwanted oscillations. We introduce an alternative technique, rooted in the non-overlapping Schwarz alternating method, originally developed for domain decomposition. In multi-body contact scenarios, this method treats each body as a separate, non-overlapping domain and prevents interpenetration using an alternating Dirichlet-Neumann iterative process. This approach has a strong theoretical foundation, eliminates the need for contact constraints, and offers flexibility, making it well-suited for multiscale and multiphysics applications. We conducted a numerical comparison between the Schwarz method and traditional methods like Lagrange Multiplier and penalty methods, focusing on a benchmark impact problem. Our results indicate that the Schwarz alternating method surpasses traditional methods in several key areas: it provides more accurate predictions for various measurable quantities and demonstrates exceptional energy conservation capabilities. Furthermore, we validated the efficiency of the Schwarz method in a three-dimensional impact problem, highlighting its innate capacity to accommodate different mesh topologies, time integration schemes, and time steps for each interacting body. Sandia National Laboratories is a multimission laboratory managed and operated by National Technology & Engineering Solutions of Sandia, LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Honeywell International Inc., for the U.S. Department of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration under contract DE-NA0003525.